In short
- Each product is described from its own public pages, with sources.
- Start from the question your office answers to, then pick the product.
- Test every option on your own data before you sign.
Microsoft retired Project Online on 30 September 2026; the Project desktop application is not affected. Planners can keep the scheduler they know. What a PMO has to replace is the portfolio layer above the schedules: the central store, the roll-up, the approvals and the reports. These are the options buyers most often weigh.
Every statement below about another product comes from that vendor's own public website and documentation, read on 14 November 2026, with a link to the source. Counts refer to the twelve capabilities we compare on every product; a capability not found in public pages is not the same as one the product lacks.
10 Project Online alternatives at a glance
| Product | Category | Best when | Stated in full |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lodestar (ours) | Strategy execution and SPM | You run large-scale or mid-size transformations and answer to a board for them | 12 of 12 |
| Planview | Enterprise portfolio suite | You need one vendor for portfolio, agile planning, value stream and services automation. | 4 of 12 |
| Planisware | Enterprise portfolio suite | You run phase-gate product development or R&D portfolios, for example in pharma or automotive. | 6 of 12 |
| Clarity by Broadcom | Enterprise portfolio suite | You already run Rally or other Broadcom ValueOps products and want them connected. | 5 of 12 |
| ServiceNow Strategic Portfolio Management | Enterprise portfolio suite | Your organisation already runs ServiceNow and wants portfolios on the same platform. | 4 of 12 |
| Smartsheet | Work management | Teams want a spreadsheet-style tool that business users configure themselves. | 4 of 12 |
| Wrike | Work management | Marketing, creative or service teams need proofing and approvals built into daily delivery. | 5 of 12 |
| monday.com | Work management | Many departments need simple, configurable boards that non-technical staff will use daily. | 4 of 12 |
| Conductor by Sensei Labs | Transformation management | You run private equity value creation plans across several portfolio companies. | 4 of 12 |
| Oracle Primavera | Scheduling tool | Contracts specify Primavera P6 (XER) schedule submissions. | 3 of 12 |
Why teams look beyond Project Online
Project Online does a great deal well, as its own pages show. Teams usually start looking when their mandate needs something its public pages do not describe, or describe only in part:
- Progress that counts only once its evidence has been approved by the right authority
- AI that reads the evidence and gives the approver what to question before signing
- Approval routes for budgets, dates, targets and stage gates, set without code to your delegation of authority
- One model from strategy to task, so the strategy office and the PMO read the same numbers
The 10 best Project Online alternatives
1. Lodestar (our product)
Strategy execution and SPM 12 of 12
An enterprise-grade platform for strategy management offices, enterprise PMOs and transformation offices. Strategy, KPIs, portfolio, schedule, budget, people, risk and approvals sit in one model, every number is backed by evidence approved by the right authority, and Polaris agents act within each person's permissions with a person approving.
Where it is strong
- One model from strategy to task: a change to a task shows on its project, pillar and KPI the same day
- Evidence before progress counts, challenged by AI and approved under your own workflows
- Approval routes for 23 kinds of change, delegation of authority and a write-once audit trail
- Agents that do the updating from Teams, Slack, WhatsApp or email, inside each person's permissions
Choose it when
- You run large-scale or mid-size transformations and answer to a board for them
- Every reported number must be traceable to approved evidence
- You want a platform tailored to your operating model, not a self-serve tool
Lodestar for strategic portfolio management
2. Planview
Enterprise portfolio suite 4 of 12 stated in full, 4 in part
Planview is a strategic portfolio management platform whose Planview Portfolios product covers strategy, planning, project execution, resources and financials, with the Anvi AI assistant available across its products. It is typically bought by enterprise PMOs, transformation offices, finance, research and development, and software product engineering organisations.
Where it is strong
- States it is trusted by more than 3,000 enterprises, naming Volvo, NatWest, Accenture and UPS. Source
- Broad platform: strategic portfolio, project portfolio, agile planning, value stream and services automation, with 60+ tool connectors. Source
- States SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001 and ISO 27701 certified infrastructure and regional data residency. Source
- Planview Portfolios lists more than 200 out-of-the-box reports and embedded Microsoft Power BI analytics. Source
Choose it when
- You need one vendor for portfolio, agile planning, value stream and services automation.
- You need 60+ prebuilt connectors to tools such as Jira, Azure DevOps and ServiceNow.
- You want capacity planning, scenario comparison and investment prioritisation at large enterprise scale.
- Your procurement requires SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001 and ISO 27701 attestations.
Lodestar and Planview, capability by capability
3. Planisware
Enterprise portfolio suite 6 of 12 stated in full, 4 in part
Planisware is a project and strategic portfolio management vendor with products for enterprise transformation, PMOs, IT, product development, capital projects and professional services. Its pages name buyers such as Ford, Philips, Pfizer and Société Générale, and industries including pharma, automotive, aerospace and the public sector.
Where it is strong
- States 600+ organisations across 35+ countries use it, with ADNOC, Zebra and Spin Master as named references. Source
- Scheduling depth: advanced Gantt chart engine, PERT diagram, WBS, earned value and phase-gate support. Source
- Operates its own single-tenant cloud across 12 data centres; shows ISO 27001 and SOC 2 badges. Source
- Lists out-of-the-box connectors including SAP, Oracle, Jira, Azure DevOps, Microsoft Teams, Slack and an open REST API. Source
Choose it when
- You run phase-gate product development or R&D portfolios, for example in pharma or automotive.
- You need heavy scheduling with Primavera P6 and Microsoft Project exchange.
- You need capital project or asset investment planning products from the same vendor.
- You require single-tenant hosting on vendor-owned infrastructure with data-location control.
Lodestar and Planisware, capability by capability
4. Clarity by Broadcom
Enterprise portfolio suite 5 of 12 stated in full, 5 in part
Clarity is Broadcom's strategic portfolio management product, part of its ValueOps line alongside Rally and ConnectALL, covering investments, roadmaps, objectives, projects, resources, financials and timesheets. Its documentation addresses large enterprise portfolio and project offices, and names Fiat Chrysler Automobiles as a customer.
Where it is strong
- Documents system-calculated earned value metrics, baselines, autoscheduling and a Gantt view with dependencies and critical path. Source
- Documents an MCP server with OAuth, naming Claude Desktop, GitHub Copilot, Cursor and Gemini CLI as clients. Source
- Vaia works with the customer's chosen model provider: Google Gemini, OpenAI ChatGPT or Microsoft Azure AI. Source
- Names Fiat Chrysler Automobiles processing 8,000 budget change requests a year in Clarity SaaS. Source
Choose it when
- You already run Rally or other Broadcom ValueOps products and want them connected.
- You need system-calculated earned value and Microsoft Project or Open Workbench scheduling.
- You want to bring your own Gemini, OpenAI or Azure model.
- You need the option to install on-premise as well as SaaS.
Lodestar and Clarity by Broadcom, capability by capability
5. ServiceNow Strategic Portfolio Management
Enterprise portfolio suite 4 of 12 stated in full, 6 in part
ServiceNow Strategic Portfolio Management is a family of applications on the ServiceNow AI Platform for strategic planning, demand, portfolio, project, resource and agile work. Its documentation addresses strategy and PMO leaders, portfolio managers, project managers and demand managers.
Where it is strong
- One product family spanning strategic planning, portfolio planning, projects, resources, agile development, cost and time cards. Source
- A documented scheduling engine: four dependency types, task constraints, slack and critical path. Source
- AI agents that autonomously monitor critical-path tasks and email the project manager a summary. Source
- An MCP server for SPM that connects any MCP-compatible AI assistant to live SPM data. Source
Choose it when
- Your organisation already runs ServiceNow and wants portfolios on the same platform.
- You need agile planning integrated with Jira or Azure DevOps beside classic projects.
- You want demand intake, resource management and time cards in one product family.
- Schedulers need to exchange plans with Microsoft Project files.
Lodestar and ServiceNow Strategic Portfolio Management, capability by capability
6. Smartsheet
Work management 4 of 12 stated in full, 4 in part
Smartsheet is a cloud work management platform built on sheets, with Gantt views, no-code automation, dashboards, portfolio features and AI agents. It is typically bought by enterprise teams and project offices across IT, operations and client delivery that want project tracking business users can configure themselves.
Where it is strong
- States that more than 85% of Fortune 500 companies trust Smartsheet; names McLaren Racing, Roche and DIRECTV. Source
- An MCP Server connects live work data to Claude, Copilot, Gemini, ChatGPT and Amazon Quick. Source
- No-code workflows with conditions and approval requests, with integrations including Slack, Teams and DocuSign. Source
- States its AI features operate within SOC 2, GDPR and data residency compliance and existing permissions. Source
Choose it when
- Teams want a spreadsheet-style tool that business users configure themselves.
- Work spans many departments, such as operations, IT and client delivery.
- Connecting work data to Claude, Copilot or ChatGPT through MCP is a priority.
- Requirements centre on no-code automation, forms and dashboards across mixed work types.
Lodestar and Smartsheet, capability by capability
7. Wrike
Work management 5 of 12 stated in full, 5 in part
Wrike is an enterprise work management platform covering planning, Gantt scheduling, approvals, proofing, resource management and AI agents, with a strategic portfolio management offering. It is typically bought by PMOs and by marketing, creative, operations and professional services teams in mid-size and large organizations.
Where it is strong
- States it was named a Leader in the 2026 Gartner Magic Quadrant for Collaborative Work Management. Source
- Gantt with four dependency types, lead and lag, critical path and reportable baselines. Source
- Built-in approvals for tasks, folders and projects, with decisions recorded on the item. Source
- Offers strategic portfolio management (Wrike SPM, powered by Shibumi) alongside project portfolio management. Source
Choose it when
- Marketing, creative or service teams need proofing and approvals built into daily delivery.
- You want detailed Gantt scheduling with Microsoft Project import in a work management tool.
- You want project and strategic portfolio management from the same vendor.
Lodestar and Wrike, capability by capability
8. monday.com
Work management 4 of 12 stated in full, 6 in part
monday.com is a no-code work platform, positioned as an AI workspace, in which teams build boards, workflows, dashboards and agents for projects and other business processes. It describes itself as best suited to mid-market and enterprise organizations where multiple teams need coordination.
Where it is strong
- States more than 250,000 customers worldwide across its products. Source
- States it is a Gartner Magic Quadrant Leader in three work management categories. Source
- No-code workflow builder with conditions, approval checkpoints, AI blocks and agent steps. Source
- States SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001, GDPR and HIPAA, with granular permissions. Source
Choose it when
- Many departments need simple, configurable boards that non-technical staff will use daily.
- You want one platform spanning work management, CRM, service and development teams.
- You want no-code workflows with approval checkpoints and agent steps.
Lodestar and monday.com, capability by capability
9. Conductor by Sensei Labs
Transformation management 4 of 12 stated in full, 6 in part
Conductor is a cloud strategy execution platform from Sensei Labs covering planning, prioritisation, execution and benefits realisation, with an AI layer called Harmony. The vendor says it is built for EPMOs, enterprise transformation and private equity value creation teams.
Where it is strong
- Benefits tracking traced to GL codes and the P&L, with risk-adjusted confidence scoring. Source
- Stage gates with several approvers, in parallel or in order, routed by rules such as investment size. Source
- Harmony AI across the product, plus an MCP server reachable from Claude, ChatGPT or Copilot. Source
- States a SOC 2 audit by Deloitte and dedicated Saudi Arabia hosting in the GCP Dammam region. Source
Choose it when
- You run private equity value creation plans across several portfolio companies.
- Benefits must be traced to GL codes and the P&L.
- You are running an M&A integration or cost transformation with a consulting partner.
- You want outside AI assistants to reach governed portfolio data through MCP.
Lodestar and Conductor by Sensei Labs, capability by capability
10. Oracle Primavera
Scheduling tool 3 of 12 stated in full, 3 in part
Primavera P6 EPPM is Oracle's enterprise planning and scheduling application, and Oracle Primavera Cloud is its cloud service combining CPM scheduling with task, resource, risk and portfolio management. It is typically bought by engineering and construction owners and contractors running large capital programmes.
Where it is strong
- Datasheet says P6 scales from one user to tens of thousands of users and millions of activities. Source
- Primavera Cloud covers all six steps of PMI's risk framework, including quantitative cost and schedule risk analysis. Source
- Ties Primavera Unifier cost codes to schedule structures for forecasting, cash flow and change management. Source
- Combines CPM contract scheduling with lean, Last Planner-aligned field task management in one cloud environment. Source
Choose it when
- Contracts specify Primavera P6 (XER) schedule submissions.
- Large engineering or construction programmes need resource-loaded CPM scheduling at scale.
- Quantitative cost and schedule risk analysis tied to the schedule is required.
- Field teams run pull planning alongside the contract schedule.
Lodestar and Oracle Primavera, capability by capability
How to choose a Project Online alternative
Start from the question your office answers to
A strategy management office answers whether the strategy is moving; an enterprise PMO answers whether the portfolio is delivering; a team answers whether its work is done. Pick the category that matches the question, then the product.
Test on your own data, from an ordinary user's seat
Load one real project, one KPI with a year of readings and your delegation of authority. Every demo looks good on the vendor's data; differences show on yours.
Ask what the product refuses
Ask to see a completion claimed with no evidence, a change raised above someone's authority, and a target restated mid-year. The answers show how governed the product really is.
Check that strategy and delivery share one model
If KPIs live in one tool and projects in another, someone reconciles them by hand every month. One model removes that work and the disagreements that come with it.
Look at how AI is allowed to act
Ask what an AI agent can change, under whose permissions, and who approves it. Ask for the record of the last change it made.
Decide between self-serve and tailored
A self-serve tool is quick to start. A governed transformation usually needs a platform configured to its operating model, approval routes and reporting cycle, with people who have run programmes on the delivery team.
For a fuller checklist, see seven tests for strategy execution software, or open the comparison of all products.
