Jira by Atlassian vs Smartsheet
How they differ, and where Lodestar fits.
What each vendor publishes about its own product, side by side on twelve capabilities, with Lodestar in the third column. On their published material the two differ on 4 of the twelve.
Capabilities stated in full
Each vendor's count is what its own public pages state, read on 14 November 2026.
For information only. What this page says about Jira by Atlassian and Smartsheet is based on their public websites and documentation, read on 14 November 2026. It may not reflect the latest releases. Lodestar is not affiliated with or endorsed by either vendor.
Jira by Atlassian
Jira is Atlassian's project and work tracking product, with Plans for cross-team planning, Rovo AI and agents, and the Strategy Collection (Focus, Talent, Align) presented as its strategic portfolio layer. It is typically bought by software, IT and business teams, from small teams to large enterprises.
- Your software teams already run backlogs, sprints and code workflows in Atlassian tools.
- You want coding agents assigned work items alongside developers.
- You need a large marketplace of integrations and apps around your delivery tool.
Smartsheet
Smartsheet is a cloud work management platform built on sheets, with Gantt views, no-code automation, dashboards, portfolio features and AI agents. It is typically bought by enterprise teams and project offices across IT, operations and client delivery that want project tracking business users can configure themselves.
- Teams want a spreadsheet-style tool that business users configure themselves.
- Work spans many departments, such as operations, IT and client delivery.
- Connecting work data to Claude, Copilot or ChatGPT through MCP is a priority.
- Requirements centre on no-code automation, forms and dashboards across mixed work types.
Lodestar
One connected model from strategy to task, with agents that work under each person's permissions and your approval rules, and evidence behind every number.
- You want everything connected in one model, strategy to task
- You want agents that work under each person's permissions and your approval rules
- Every reported number must trace to evidence the right authority approved
Capability by capability
Twelve capabilities in four groups. Every statement about Jira by Atlassian and Smartsheet comes from that vendor's own public pages and links to its source.
| Capability | Jira by Atlassian | Smartsheet | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Connected modelJira by Atlassian 1 of 3Smartsheet 0 of 3Lodestar 3 of 3 | |||
| One model, strategy to task | Stated Describes goals linked to Jira work, and OKRs and strategic goals connected to program delivery through the Strategy Collection apps (Focus, Align). Source | In part vsActual, announced with a sign-up for availability updates, is described as linking every funded initiative and company goals to live execution. Source | Yes Strategy, KPIs, portfolio, schedule, budget, people, risks and approvals sit in one model. A change to a task shows on its project, its pillar and its KPI the same day. |
| Scheduling engine | In part Describes timelines with dependencies, capacity and scenario planning in Plans; baselines and Microsoft Project or Primavera file exchange were not found. Source | In part Describes Gantt view with dependencies, critical path and baselines; exchange of Microsoft Project or Primavera P6 files was not found in the pages read. Source | Yes Gantt with dependencies, critical path and baselines. Imports Microsoft Project plans saved as XML and Primavera P6 as PMXML, and exports both. |
| Earned value | Not found Not found in the vendor's public pages. | Not found Not found in the vendor's public pages. | Yes Planned value, earned value, actual cost, CPI, SPI and estimate at completion for every active project with a budget and dates. |
| Governed executionJira by Atlassian 1 of 3Smartsheet 1 of 3Lodestar 3 of 3 | |||
| Approval workflows you configure | Stated Describes workflow approval steps that hold a transition until a named approver decides, alongside transition conditions and validators. Source | Stated Describes automation workflows built from templates with trigger and condition blocks and approval requests, with actions that follow an approved or declined outcome. Source | Yes Workflow Studio sets approval routes for 23 kinds of change without code: value thresholds, committees, delegation and a deadline on every step. |
| Evidence before progress counts | In part Describes validators that block work that is not ready and approval steps on transitions; a proof-attachment requirement was not found. Source | Not found Not found in the vendor's public pages. | Yes A completion needs the evidence its gate names and approval by the authority your workflow assigns, never the claimant. Until then a claimed 100% counts as 95%. |
| A record that cannot be edited | In part Describes agent and user actions recorded in work item history and admin audit logs; not described as immutable in the pages read. Source | In part Describes Activity Log as a detailed audit trail of changes, access and sharing; the pages read do not describe it as immutable or tamper-evident. Source | Yes Audit and decision logs are write-once and hash-chained. Approved evidence is frozen with a SHA-256 fingerprint. |
| Agentic AIJira by Atlassian 3 of 5Smartsheet 3 of 5Lodestar 5 of 5 | |||
| AI that challenges the evidence | Not found Not found in the vendor's public pages. | Not found Not found in the vendor's public pages. | Yes Polaris reads the submitted files, works out the value without seeing the claim, and gives the approver what holds up and what to question. A sparring partner; it never approves. |
| AI agents that do work | Stated Describes Rovo and third-party agents that can be assigned work, break work down, create and update work items and draft status updates. Source | Stated Describes agents that build workspaces, dashboards and reports, review data quality, create automations and deliver scheduled summaries and risk insights. Source | Yes Seven AI advisors and a Chief of Staff read the programme each cycle. The Polaris assistant works with each person's own permissions: it sees and changes only what that person may. |
| A person approves AI changes | In part Describes approval steps customers add so a person signs off agent work, recorded in work item history; autonomy or approval is set per task. Source | Stated States that any changes to sheets require the user's approval, that the change is shown before it applies, and that all agent actions are auditable. Source | Yes Each AI-proposed change is a card showing before and after. A person presses Apply, and the decision is kept in a write-once log. |
| Updating from chat or email | Stated Describes keeping work up to date from tools such as Slack and Gmail with AI assistance, and Rovo capturing work from Slack and email. Source | In part Describes workflows that people respond to via apps, email, or platforms such as Slack and Teams. Source | Yes An owner answers in plain words in Microsoft Teams, Slack or WhatsApp, in the app or by email reply, and the assistant proposes the update for approval. |
| Open to your AI assistants | Stated Describes the Atlassian MCP Server connecting AI clients such as ChatGPT, Claude and Cursor to Atlassian data, with read, write and delete permissions. Source | Stated The Smartsheet MCP Server connects Smartsheet data to Claude, Microsoft Copilot, Gemini, ChatGPT, Amazon Quick and other compatible AI tools, within existing permissions. Source | Yes An MCP server lets assistants such as Claude, Microsoft 365 Copilot and Cursor read the programme under each user's own permissions. |
| LanguageJira by Atlassian 0 of 1Smartsheet 0 of 1Lodestar 1 of 1 | |||
| Arabic, right to left | Not found Not found in the vendor's public pages. | Not found Not found in the vendor's public pages. | Yes Arabic and English throughout, with full right-to-left layout. |
Read on 14 November 2026. Products change; if something here is out of date, tell us and we will correct it.
Where each one is strong
From each vendor's own pages.
Jira by Atlassian
- States that 300,000+ companies and 85% of the Fortune 500 use Atlassian products. Source
- States 3,000+ integrations in the Atlassian Marketplace and a community of 4.5M+ members. Source
- Work items can be assigned to Rovo and third-party agents such as Cursor, GitHub Copilot and Claude. Source
- Plans offers cross-team timelines, dependencies, capacity, scenarios and a custom hierarchy above epics. Source
Smartsheet
- States that more than 85% of Fortune 500 companies trust Smartsheet; names McLaren Racing, Roche and DIRECTV. Source
- An MCP Server connects live work data to Claude, Copilot, Gemini, ChatGPT and Amazon Quick. Source
- No-code workflows with conditions and approval requests, with integrations including Slack, Teams and DocuSign. Source
- States its AI features operate within SOC 2, GDPR and data residency compliance and existing permissions. Source
The full pages: Lodestar and Jira by Atlassian Lodestar and Smartsheet
Sources
Read on 14 November 2026. Product names are trademarks of their owners, used here only to identify the products. Lodestar is not affiliated with or endorsed by either vendor.
- atlassian.com/software/jira
- atlassian.com/collections/strategy
- atlassian.com/software/jira/guides/advanced-roadmaps/overview
- atlassian.com/software/jira/guides/agentic-engineering/human-in-the-loop
- atlassian.com/software/jira/guides/agentic-engineering/guardrails-and-safety
- atlassian.com/software/jira/ai
- atlassian.com/software/jira/features
- atlassian.com/platform/rovo-mcp
- atlassian.com/software/jira/agents
- smartsheet.com
- smartsheet.com/vsactual
- help.smartsheet.com/articles/765675-work-with-gantt-chart
- help.smartsheet.com/articles/2479276-request-approval-from-stakeholders
- smartsheet.com/platform/agents
- smartsheet.com/platform/features
- smartsheet.com/ai